Guerendo was a multi-sport athlete in high school, playing football, basketball and running track.
A native of Clayton, Indiana, Guerendo played his first two years of high school sports at Cascade High School and his final two years at Avon High School. Before playing as a running back throughout college, Guerendo primarily played as a wide receiver in high school. During his senior year (2018), he tallied 1,258 yards and 16 touchdowns to help his team go 10-3 and was named Indiana's Mr. Football, a position award for the state's top wide receiver.
Guerendo also lettered in basketball and was a three-time state champion in track. He won the 100-meter dash with a 10.51 time and was on the state-winning 4x100 meter relay team in his senior year.